Belle de Jour’s simple guide to criticism

Comment
Share |

Rosie Boycott Bingo:

So here it is! Your cut-and-keep guide to what people say vs. what people really mean: post-coming out edition. Hope you find it useful too! I’m considering making a board game version of this and calling it Rosie Boycott Bingo.

  • When someone says:
    “I have too much respect for myself ever to do that.”
    What they mean is:
    “My self-esteem is so fragile that stepping outside the mainstream would mess it up for life.”
  • When someone says:
    “She’s not even that good-looking.”
    What they mean is:
    “This woman’s choices make me uncomfortable but I don’t have the intelligence to address that so will criticise her looks instead.”
  • When someone says:
    “See? Other people in her family have problems. That explains everything.”
    What they mean is:
    “In spite of the fact that all families have difficulties, I’m going to pretend otherwise in order to make an ad hominem attack.”
  • When someone says:
    “Stories like this glamourise a trade that enslaves and kills women.”
    What they mean is:
    “I don’t actually know the difference between the separate issues affecting call girls, massage parlours, brothels, and streetwalkers, and I’m not going to bother finding out.”
  • When someone says:
    “I wouldn’t pay £300 for that.”
    What they mean is:
    “I think a woman’s value, sexual or otherwise, is entirely based on her looks.”
  • When someone says:
    “I have similar factors in my life and didn’t choose this route.”
    What they mean is:
    “I am unfamiliar with the notion that free will more or less assures that people will makes decisions I would not have done.”
  • When someone says:
    “If she liked the job so much why isn’t she still doing it?”
    What they mean is:
    “I don’t believe people can, or should, change direction in their lives without self-hatred and regret.”